If you are in the chiropractic profession, these words hit you in the gut and give you the 'creeps'. The same kind of creepy feeling you can't shake after walking through a spider-web in the dark. Yuck! These thoughts about chiropactic have plagued our profession for years, and I don't know about you, but I am sooo over it!
Chiropractic, in general, is a much safer approach to health care than medical care. It is restorative, preventative, drug free, noninvasive, and has no side affects. This is shown to be true by two considerations. First, chiropractors, by-in-large, are careful, conservative adjusters, and use no more force than is needed to get the proper adjustment. Second, patients who experience chiropractic adjustments not only tolerate them well, but think of them in such a positive and beneficial way, that they often try to "adjust" themselves at home (which we then must gently but MAJORLY discourage). On the contrary, I don't seem to find a large population of people who develop the desire to give themselves injections or surgery at home, no matter how needed the procedure may be. And if this were not evidence enough, lets look at an industry who's wallet is at stake when evaluating these risks... Malpractice Insurance Companies. They openly tell us that, of all the different types of doctors, it is the chiropractor, that has, by far, the lowest-risk practices. In fact, chiropractors enjoy the lowest malpractice insurance rates of ALL the health care disciplines!
We have Hollywood to thank for our irrational fear of the fragility of our necks. How many action movies have you seen that show the apparent ease with which a "ninja warrior" or mafia thug goes around casually, and almost effortlessly, eliminating all those who would dare oppose him with a quick twist of the head. Ha! Give your body and bone structure a liiiiiiittle more credit than that. Food for thought... The average boxer hits with a force of about 800-1,000 lbs across someone's chin. Notice that, in most cases, this does not break the neck. Now, compare that to a chiropractic adjustment which is, at most, 70-80 lbs. God made your body strong... don't underestimate it. :)
Ok... lets think about this rationally. Consider the following ABSOLUTELY TRUE statement: Some people have strokes directly after eating pizza. What was your first reaction to this statement? This question is the first step needed to make a rational assessment of the risks of eating pizza. The second question you want to ask is: How many is people is "some"? If one out of every 1,000 people stroke after eating pizza, then Papa John's Pizza everywhere would be closing down until this epidemic could be stopped. However, if that number was closer to 1 out of every 2-3,000,000 people, the fear level would significantly drop. Everyone knows that there is a risk of choking on a pepperoni, but the love of pizza causes patrons to flock to these restaurants anyway. Why? Because everyone who eats pizza casually accepts the small level of risk in order to enjoy their favorite Italian dish.
Now... lets look at this ABSOLUTELY TRUE statement: Some patients have strokes after receiving a cervical spine adjustment. What was your first reaction to this statement? And again, the next question: How many is some? As people have started looking at the "risk of stroke" statistics a little closer, they are seeing that, as a group, people under regular chiropractic care, appear to have a slightly LOWER risk of stroke than an equivalent group of those not under chiropractic care! WOW!
I will close with this quote from NCMIC (malpractice insurance company) and statistics:
"On analysis, Spinal Manipulative Therapy (SMT) as delivered by chiropractors is one of the most conservative, least invasive and safest of procedures in the provision of heal care services. The risks of SMT pale when compared to known medical risks. Chiropractors, by their training and skill in SMT and special emphasis on the spine, are the best positioned to deliver this mode of health care to the public."
- 99% of strokes occur within the BRAIN
- 1% of strokes occur in the neck
Research is showing that 1 : 5,850,000 chiropractic adjustments MAY cause stroke... here are some relative numbers:
- Being struck by lightening 1 : 700,000
- Drowning in a bathtub 1 : 818,051
- Fatal fall down stairs 1 180,188
- Accidental suffocation in bed 1 : 565,700
I would say this myth is officially... BUSTED!